The Reality of Hypotheticals: a "what if" scenario
Last Saturday I finished 212th out of 340. I want to be honest about that, because honesty matters, and because I was perfectly happy with it until I got home.
That evening I sat down with the results page and a spreadsheet. Somewhere among the 211 people ahead of me, I reasoned, there could have been a trans woman. I did not see one. I could not describe one. But I could not rule one out, and in our club, a thing you cannot rule out is a thing that has basically been confirmed. By nine o'clock I had removed her from the results. By ten I was 211th. By eleven I was furious on behalf of the woman who would have come 211th, who is me.
I then filtered the results to women only. I was 64th. Without the runner I had not seen, I would have been 63rd. Sixty-third! A position nobody has ever been presented with anything for, because nobody has ever been presented with anything at parkrun, and yet a position that was, in a very real and entirely hypothetical sense, taken from me.
Some will say a place at parkrun means nothing. There is no podium, no prize, no medal, and the woman in 62nd was pushing a double buggy and talking on the phone. I say a place is a place, especially one I did not get. Nobody is speaking up for 63rd. I have decided it is going to be me.
It has been pointed out that 147 men also finished ahead of me, and that I have not written to anyone about any of them. This is different, for reasons that will be set out in a footnote, once I have thought of them.
The deeper point is about fairness. Fairness is not about who actually ran; it is about who I have decided might have run, and the place I ought to have had, worked out retrospectively, with a filter. Anything else is just a jog in a park.
I invite you to join me in being furious about a person who may not have been there, taking a place that does not matter. Bring a flask.
Place actually achieved: 212th · Place I am owed: 211th · Trans runners identified: 0